Avoid R&D roles unless it's in a factory - Product Development Engineer bei 3M: Mitarbeiterbewertung

1.0
18. Jan. 2023
Empfehlen
CEO-Befürwortung
Geschäftsprognose

Pros

Good pension benefit and employee stock purchase plan. Good team-mates, I have made life-long friendships from this role. Really cutting edge work being done in factories. Easy job for sales - just sell the quality products the parent organisation in the US delivers.

Kontras

I spent over 4 years working at 3M. I was hired as a software graduate but the company didn't seem to know how to turn a graduate into a software programmer. I had major impostor syndrome and I was afraid I wouldn't be able to find a job anywhere else. I found my time there to be a truly spirit crushing experience. I worked on a variety of projects, many experimental. I had the experience of attending meetings with people who knew a project was due to be scrapped and would lie to you about it (to this day, I still don't understand why). Consequence was that I would continue to work on something pointless instead of re-directing my time elsewhere. Various cost-cutting measures introduced with false economies. I found that I suddenly had to do random administrative tasks that had previously been handled by a corporate team. My requests for help from that team were rebuffed (no performance appraisal benefit in them helping me). General technical incompetence. I witnessed a middle manager overseeing a team of well paid engineers ask why the data in a relational database couldn't all be stored in one table. Corporate IT asked me to share my password with them in order to fix something on my computer. An ideal environment for corporate psychopaths and self promoters. In my first week I attended a presentation by senior employees about career management. The advice was "manage your manager". This turned out to be true. People who spent time promoting themselves to their managers seemed to do a lot better than those who just kept their heads down, worked hard and delivered results. I saw a beautiful house of cards get built, the builder promote someone else into looking after it before taking the credit and moving on, leaving a live hand grenade behind. Parent company in the US seemed to keep appointing a new MD. Depending on what the current numbers were like the corporate strategy alternated between "get rid of people to get costs down" and "boost R&D spending to increase the share of revenue coming from new products". After a round of redundancies where mid-level technical staff were let go because "R&D efforts weren't in line with corporate strategy" but none of the technical leaders were let go, despite "wasting" resource on the very same thing, I decided to deal with my anxiety and just leave.

avatar
Reaktion von 3M
3y
Thank you so much for taking the time to share your insights and feedback. R&D is so integral to what we do and what we're known for. We'll be sure to forward on your advice to the right people.

Mehr Bewertungen zu 3M entdecken

5.0
15. Juni 2026
Empfehlen
CEO-Befürwortung
Geschäftsprognose

Pros

Good company to work for.

Kontras

Large corp culture for employees

4.0
28. Juni 2026
Empfehlen
CEO-Befürwortung
Geschäftsprognose

Pros

Compensation is genuinely competitive — one of the stronger-paying manufacturing roles you'll find in the area. Benefits package is comprehensive and well above average. The retirement account and stock options are a real standout, especially for a machine operator role; 3M clearly invests in its employees long-term. Day-to-day, the people on the floor make the job. Coworkers were hardworking and easy to get along with, which goes a long way in a production environment. Upper management is what you'd expect from a large corporation — a bit removed from the floor — but that's pretty standard for a company of that size, Not a deal breaker.

Kontras

The shift schedule is rough. Rotating between 12-hour days and nights on a swing schedule sounds manageable on paper, but constantly flipping your sleep schedule takes a real toll over time. Work-life balance is difficult to maintain when your "days off" are often spent just recovering and readjusting, and you can easily miss out on normal life things — social plans, family time, errands — simply because your schedule doesn't line up with the rest of the world that week. Upper management can also be a friction point. When people who haven't touched the machines in years (or ever) come to the floor with strong opinions about how things should run, it creates frustration. The folks actually operating the equipment day in and day out develop real expertise, and that doesn't always feel acknowledged from above.

Bewertungen anzeigen nach: Hilfreich|Sterne|Datum|Alle